Compare 353 general surgeons in Pittsburgh, PA. Check ratings, insurance, and availability.
353
General Surgeons
100%
Accepting patients
77%
Most common: MD
Ranked by Clarity Score, based on profile detail, verification, and patient activity.
Pittsburgh is a UPMC town, and there is no getting around it. UPMC is one of the largest nonprofit health systems in the country, and it functions as both a hospital operator and an insurance company. Allegheny Health Network (AHN), backed by Highmark Blue Cross, provides the main alternative. The rivalry between UPMC and Highmark shapes nearly every healthcare decision a Pittsburgh resident makes.
Pittsburgh has 353 general surgeons. The most common credential is MD (77%). 100% are currently accepting new patients. Practitioners see patients in neighborhoods including Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, Lawrenceville, and Strip District.
The Oakland neighborhood is Pittsburgh's medical hub, home to UPMC Presbyterian, UPMC Magee-Womens, and UPMC Children's. Allegheny General Hospital sits on the North Side. Pittsburgh's geography (rivers, bridges, hills) makes cross-city travel unpredictable, so most residents choose the hospital system closest to their neighborhood. The T light rail connects South Hills communities to downtown, but bus routes are the primary transit option for hospital access.
Nearby hospitals include UPMC Presbyterian, UPMC Shadyside, and Allegheny General Hospital. Local training programs run through University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and Carnegie Mellon University. UPMC is one of the largest nonprofit health systems in the US, employing over 95,000 people.
The Pittsburgh insurance market is a two-player game: UPMC Health Plan and Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield. Employer plans typically align with one system. On the ACA marketplace, both plans compete on price and network breadth. Medicaid managed care is served by UPMC for You, Highmark Wholecare (formerly Gateway Health), and AmeriHealth Caritas. Choosing between the two plans is, effectively, choosing between the two hospital systems. 62% accept Medicare.
The consultation includes a review of your symptoms, imaging, and lab results. The surgeon will perform a focused physical exam and discuss whether surgery is recommended, what the procedure involves, risks and benefits, expected recovery time, and alternatives. Many general surgery procedures are now done laparoscopically (small incisions, camera-guided), meaning shorter hospital stays and faster recovery than traditional open surgery.
The first question every new Pittsburgh resident should answer: are you on UPMC insurance or Highmark insurance? Your insurance determines which hospital system and physicians are in-network. This is not optional advice; it is the most important healthcare decision you will make here.
See a general surgeon for gallbladder problems (gallstones), hernias (inguinal, umbilical, incisional), appendicitis, breast lumps or biopsies, colon polyps too large for endoscopic removal, skin lesions requiring excision, thyroid nodules requiring surgery, abscesses needing drainage, and any abdominal condition your doctor believes needs surgical evaluation.
Consultation copay: $30-75 · Gallbladder removal: $5,000-15,000 · Hernia repair: $3,000-10,000 · Appendectomy: $5,000-20,000
Pittsburgh, PA has 353 licensed general surgeons. 100% are currently accepting new patients, so finding an available provider should be straightforward.
Yes. 100% of general surgeons in Pittsburgh, PA are currently accepting new patients. You can filter your search on FindClarity to show only providers who are taking new patients.
The Pittsburgh insurance market is defined by the UPMC Health Plan and Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield rivalry. Employer plans tend to offer one or the other, rarely both. On the ACA marketplace, UPMC Health Plan and Highmark compete directly. Medicaid is administered through UPMC for You, Highmark Wholecare (formerly Gateway Health), and AmeriHealth Caritas.
A surgical consultation copay is $40 to $75. Hernia repair costs $3,000 to $7,000 (facility + surgeon). Gallbladder removal runs $5,000 to $12,000. Appendectomy costs $5,000 to $15,000. Actual costs in Pittsburgh, PA depend on the provider and your insurance plan. Surgical costs involve multiple bills: surgeon fee, anesthesiologist fee, facility fee, pathology, and possibly assistant surgeon. Ask for a bundled estimate in advance. Out-of-network anesthesiologists at in-network facilities are a common surprise bill.
Pittsburgh healthcare revolves around the UPMC vs. AHN/Highmark divide. UPMC Health Plan members can use UPMC facilities at in-network rates. Highmark members have full access to AHN facilities and limited (though expanding) access to UPMC. Before choosing a primary care doctor, verify that your insurance covers their hospital system.
MD stands for Doctor of Medicine and DO stands for Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine. Both are equivalent qualifications. In Pittsburgh, PA, 77% hold the MD credential and 7% hold DO. The difference is in training pathway, not quality of care.
62% of general surgeons in Pittsburgh, PA accept Medicare. Medicare Part B covers surgical consultations, and Part A covers inpatient surgical procedures. The surgeon's fee, anesthesia, and facility charges are typically separate bills. Standard deductible and coinsurance apply. You can filter for Medicare-accepting providers on FindClarity.
UPMC and Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield have been in a long-running business dispute because UPMC operates its own competing insurance plan. As a result, UPMC hospitals and many UPMC physicians are not fully in-network for Highmark insurance members, and vice versa. A consent decree required some continued access, but the terms have evolved. Always verify your coverage before scheduling appointments.
It depends. Under various agreements, some UPMC facilities and physicians remain accessible to Highmark members, particularly for emergency care and certain community hospitals. However, flagship UPMC hospitals like Presbyterian and Shadyside may be out-of-network for Highmark plans. Check with both your insurer and the provider before booking.
Top accepted carriers in Pittsburgh, PA include unitedhealthcare, medicare, centene, qhp-54192, and cigna.
Surgical consultations and procedures are covered under medical insurance. Most surgeries require prior authorization. Verify that both the surgeon and the surgical facility (hospital or ambulatory surgery center) are in-network. Ambulatory surgery centers often have lower facility fees than hospitals for the same procedure. Ask about total estimated costs including surgeon, facility, and anesthesia fees.